Best whisky for Old Fashioned (UK)
The best whisky for an Old Fashioned is usually bourbon — corn-heavy sweetness pairs with sugar and Angostura bitters. High-rye bourbons (Bulleit, Wild Turkey 101) add spice that cuts through the sweetness. Scotch makes a drier, sometimes smoky Old Fashioned.
Because the spirit is 60ml and almost nothing else dilutes it, mid-range bottles (£25–£35) are the sweet spot — not bottom-shelf, not XO.
Best bourbon for Old Fashioneds UK
Buffalo Trace — vanilla and caramel, widely available. Bulleit Bourbon — higher rye, spicier finish. Woodford Reserve — richer, good for guests. Wild Turkey 101 — bold at 50.5% ABV — use slightly less sugar.
Scotch and rye alternatives
Blended Scotch (Monkey Shoulder, Famous Grouse) — drier Old Fashioned with less vanilla. Rye whiskey (Rittenhouse, Sazerac) — traditional Manhattan territory but excellent in Old Fashioneds if you like peppery spice.
Old Fashioned method reminder
60ml spirit, 1 sugar cube or 5ml simple syrup, 2–3 dashes Angostura, large ice cube, stir 30 seconds. Express orange peel — do not muddle fruit salad into the glass.
See our bourbon cocktail hub for Manhattan, Whiskey Sour and Boulevardier recipes.
Shop picks
Bottles for this guide
- Check price →
Buffalo Trace
Benchmark Old Fashioned bourbon
- Check price →
Bulleit Bourbon
High-rye spice
- Check price →
Angostura Bitters
Required for the classic
Frequently asked questions
What is the best whisky for an Old Fashioned?
Buffalo Trace or Bulleit bourbon for a classic sweet profile. High-rye bourbon if you want more spice.
Best scotch for Old Fashioned?
Blended Scotch — Monkey Shoulder or Famous Grouse. Lightly peated Scotch adds smoke; avoid heavy Islay unless you want intensity.
Bourbon or rye for Old Fashioned?
Bourbon is sweeter and more beginner-friendly. Rye is drier and spicier — historically common in the US.
Best whisky for Old Fashioned UK supermarket?
Buffalo Trace and Bulleit are stocked in many Tesco and Majestic stores; Woodford Reserve in larger supermarkets.
Cocktail recipes
Build a drink from your cabinet
Free AI cocktail generator — three recipes in seconds.
Open the generator →